UK Anti-Doping’s investigation into steroid use among Welsh junior rugby players is ongoing, but suggests an endemic desire to take dangerous shortcuts in the name of superior size and strength. Our increased knowledge and awareness of the dangers of football are believed to be a big reason the NFL’s TV ratings have gone down each of the past two seasons. There has also been a view that double-tackles should be banned. The rising concussion crisis in the NFL has received plenty of media coverage, as has the impact football has on even high school athletes. The number of diagnosed concussions in the National Football League skyrocketed to 274 in 2015, while the 9-team Canadian Football League reported 50 concussions in 2010. Or a sport of guile and skill and sidestepping evasion? In any collision sport, injuries are a relatively common and inevitable part of the game. It begs the question: which sport is more dangerous, rugby or football? Since they don’t have hard plastic protecting their heads like football players do, rugby players feel less invincible and aren’t going to use their head as a weapon. On Thursday, three senior figures in French rugby, Bernard Laporte, Serge Simon and Paul Goze, will meet with World Rugby grandees Bill Beaumont and Brett Gosper to appraise the situation. I … Rugby requires players to touch the ball down to the ground after they’ve crossed the goal line, resulting in a try that is worth 5 points. A sport of massive collision and eyeballs-out confrontation? READ MORE: * 'Make rugby safer,' urges French minister * French club mourns academy player * Kiwis join tribute to late French team-mate. There are some minor differences between the two sports (for example, a rugby field is 109 yards long, compared to the 100-yard field used in football), but let’s just highlight the biggest differences that affect player safety. This varies between playing level (professional versus club, adolescents versus children, and so on), but typically increases as the … Although knee and ankle injuries are the most common in football, STOP Sports Injuries also acknowledged that head injuries (most notably concussions) were also a major concern. More and more rugby players continue to suffer from head injuries, resulting in memory loss and often, epilepsy. This common method of attempting to advance the ball often makes intended receivers prone to injury as they look back or up in the air to try to catch the ball. OPINION: For the first time in 50 years of playing and reporting on rugby, I have reservations about encouraging children to take up the sport. That needs rectifying. Is rugby dangerous? First, let's talk about one of the main reasons that rugby is dangerous. Is rugby too dangerous to play? The minute silences have to be more than token gestures. Sports betting and gambling laws vary by jurisdiction. Due to the physical demands of both sports, injuries are frequent in both rugby and football. So, the rugby players should be ready to receive and face a wide array of injuries as a number of collisions will occur among players. Meanwhile, football commonly produces more injuries than any other North American sport. French sources tell me that the incidence of serious injury at the scrum has dropped dramatically since the "hit" was taken out of the engagement. How dangerous is rugby? The structure is different from other sports, but isn’t much more dangerous. In football, players simply need to break the plane of the goal line with the ball in order to score a touchdown, worth 6 points. On Friday (Saturday NZ time)  at Kingsholm, there was a minute's silence for 19-year-old Stade Francais forward Nicolas Chauvin, who died last week after a cardiac arrest brought on by the trauma of breaking his neck in a match a few days earlier. Although the opposing player isn’t allowed to hit the intended receiver until the ball arrives, the receiver often isn’t prepared for the hit or even aware that their opponent is there. Why Rugby Is a Dangerous Sport. All protocols were observed, all due diligence practised. The less-violent nature of rugby is reflected in the equipment that is worn. Rugby may involve more actual tackles over the course of a game, due to the constant flow of a match, but I believe that the players also have a lot more respect for their opponents. But there has at least to be introspection and scrutiny if there are not to be more Chauvins. One fatality is terrible enough. Although cited, no suspensions were handed to either Umaga or Mealamu. On Sunday, we stood again, at Welford Road, as supporters had done at grounds all round Europe across the weekend. Some of them have been compelled by such injuries, to retire early in their lives to avoid suffering more damage to their But if Americans truly are changing the channel because they don’t want to see bodies writhing in pain on the field or players undergoing concussion protocol, they aren’t the only ones. Too much emphasis has been put on brawn and not enough on brain. Unlike rugby, football allows the ball to be passed forward (as long as the player passing the ball is behind the line of scrimmage). The lawmakers have taken steps to reduce the danger levels at that phase, law adjustments which appear to be working. Published by Anaya Cole on 08/09/2019. They are able to throw their entire body into t… Both football and rugby require a player to bring their opponent to the ground by tackling them, making the two sports among the most physical games in the world. Rugby may be a more physically demanding sport to play, however, because the game flow is much more fluid. The evidence is hotly disputed. Rugby isn’t a dangerous sport, but like all contact sport there are always risks and while the risks of injury are just as high in football, the type of injuries sustained in … You can also score points in both sports by kicking the ball through a pair of uprights at the opponent’s end of the field, either when converting after a score (a convert in football is worth 1 point, compared to 2 in rugby) or from the field of play (a field goal in football is worth 3 points, as are penalty kicks/drop goals in rugby.). It pains me to say this as a long-time football fan who loved playing the game at a high school level, but I would much rather see my son on a rugby pitch than on the football gridiron. Rugby is a contact sport, and in any contact sport however good the rules are injuries will occur. This feels like a seminal moment for the game. For many years, I would shrug after a catastrophic injury such as afflicted the likes of former England and Leicester prop Matt Hampson, sympathise, of course, but conclude that the good bits in rugby outweigh the bad by a factor of 99 per cent. There are much safer games to be played, and the long-term effects of concussions can be catastrophic. The excessive price of concussions related to rugby and American soccer dangers the gamers’ long-term well being. 'Rugby IS dangerous - and we're not doing enough to protect kids from injury': Leading expert warns young players risk depression, memory loss and speech problems Allyson Pollock is … Let’s take a closer look at both sports and try to find out. Is Andy Reid The Best Head Coach In The NFL? comment! Due to the physical demands of both sports, injuries are frequent in both rugby and football. Falling into the water from sea level might sound like a … Let us make sure that good things happen as a result. Rugby is one of the most dangerous and challenging sports in the world. He’s a fierce researcher with a strong appetite to deliver accurate and relevant facts that in turn have led to past success with picks and DFS advice across the board. And yet, still, a young man died having a bit of fun. Surfers are true adrenaline junkies. America's Cup: Where to now for Dean Barker? Football players achieve that sort of force through mostly athleticism, of course, but some of it comes down to their tackling approaches. To be honest, I’d rather that my children not play in either of these two sports. According to STOP (Sports Trauma and Overuse Prevention) Sports Injuries, an initiative of the American Orthopaedic Society, nearly 1 million athletes under the age of 18 were treated by doctors and clinics for football-related injuries in 2007. Not if you’re taught right, says England flanker and London Wasps captain James Haskell. By comparison, head injuries account for around 20%. That was 10 years ago, and the numbers have only gone up as awareness and diagnosis of head injuries in football have both increased. Finally, passing the ball backward is permitted in both sports, although backward passes happen a lot more in rugby. Pollock cites a study she was involved in with six Edinburgh schools, which logged an alarming 37 injuries in … There are concerns beyond rugby that the policy could have a cascading effect on other sports' governing bodies and make the climate for trans people more dangerous. I am a rugby player and my last game was in the month of June and i got an injury. Report: How dangerous is Rugby Rugby is a sport that is gaining traction around the world, particularly as the Rugby World Cup gains in popularity in each outing. We are not able to verify the legality of the information we provide, or your ability to use any sites that are linked to on this site, for every combination of your location, the sites’ location, and the type of service those sites provide. Rugby players are permitted to wear helmets, but those helmets are made out of soft plastic and aren’t designed to protect the head from impact (they’re intended to protect ears in a scrum.) Rory Best and Peter O'Mahony tackle Brodie Retallick last month. Click on the button below to get free picks delivered to your email daily... TheSportsGeek.com is not an online gambling operator, or a gambling site of any kind. A 2014 report published by the British Journal of Sports Medicine claimed that concussions were the most commonly-reported injury in professional rugby union in England. rugby was made too have fun and not hurt each other, but today people play rugby too hurt each other and not play for the fun of the game. Increasingly rugby gamers proceed to undergo from head accidents, leading to reminiscence loss and infrequently, epilepsy. But then the referee's whistle would blow and it was back to the norm, huge blokes crashing into each other, monstrous hits, bold, fearless play. Rugby players suffer more cuts and bruises but football players get concussions, broken bones, torn ligaments and heat-related injuries. The most common type of injuries in each sport may differ, but both share a concern when it comes to the most serious injuries of all: concussions. As rugby is a high intensity ball sport, it is … There’s nothing quite like the feeling when you are in a … At the professional level, however, concussions in rugby are much more prevalent. The main objective of both sports is also similar: cross the opponent’s goal line with possession of the ball. There was no foul play involved. In fact, the possibilities of rugby injuries are almost above 90%. This is about reflecting on what the game has become and working out if enough is being done to ensure that it is as safe as it is possible to be within those 80 minutes. Rough is one thing, like a bit of 'how's yer father' in the rucks and mauls but as far as injuries go it's not THAT bad at … Up to the age of 9, it is a non-contact sport, whereby touch or flag rugby is played. In rugby, it is physically dangerous. Football players also wear much heavier shoulder pads than rugby players do, and football players wear protective equipment on their upper legs as well. The trials in the Under-20 championship to lower the acceptable height of the tackle to the nipple have proved positive, with significant reductions in the amount of concussions reported. The sport has to work out if it has become too dangerous, too big, too brutal for its own good. But if I’m forced to pick between the two, I personally believe football is more dangerous than rugby. The most common type of injuries in each sport may differ, but both share a concern when it comes to the most serious injuries of all: ... Search is on for 'armed and dangerous… Football is played at much higher speeds than rugby is (generally). My coach always taught us that if we used proper form and played correctly we would generally be fine. Each moment of the match will be tough and critical for players. TV viewership and attendance numbers for rugby matches, approximately 250% more tackles are made during a top-level rugby game, approximately 1 in 4 players will be injured during a youth rugby season, concussions in the National Football League skyrocketed to 274 in 2015, Ultimate Guide to Super Bowl Betting in California. American Magic skipper Terry Hutchinson chokes back tears after 'brutal' Prada Cup exit, Surfer rescued in Wellington and flown to hospital in serious condition, Landlords publishing 'bad tenants' lists online could be breaking the law, Prada Cup semifinal live: American Magic out of the America's Cup as Luna Rossa win semifinal, Recap: Australia pushes back decision on quarantine-free flights from New Zealand to Sunday, Man dead after being swept out to sea, child rescued from water near Timaru, Quiz: Afternoon trivia challenge: January 30, 2021, Listeria warning issued for salads sold at hundreds of stores. However, there are also significant differences between the sports that drastically affect participants’ potential for injury. Identifying Early NHL Divisional Odds Shifts. In rugby you have to be constantly tackling the other team or the other players. In the other hand, when the time goes on, kids start to grow, and the game starts becoming tougher and tougher as the competitiveness increases. Football and rugby also differ in which ways contact with opponents is permitted. It will not be a straightforward process. The same sort of change needs to happen again. Brenton is a fan of most all sports but specializes in hockey, baseball, football, basketball, and golf. There are other facets in the sport that need addressing, notably the more philosophical one of what we want rugby to be about. It has at least started to focus properly on concussion, albeit it took media lobbying from journalistic stalwarts such as Sam Peters to keep highlighting concerns. He takes great pride in his success and loves nothing more than to share that success for the benefit of everyone involved. But increasingly there is concern that rugby has become too dangerous. 08/09/2019. It would be easy to move on again, to pretend that all is right with rugby's little world. And when it comes to tackling, rugby requires players to attempt to wrap their arms around their opponent, a stark contrast to the shoulder-first hits that are permitted in football. In rugby, the only breaks in the action are for scrums, throw-ins, or after scoring plays, and players play both offense and defense. Brenton’s biggest goal is to deliver readers with the picks and advice that can build their bankroll. Concussions are always a possibility. The most common injury in youth rugby is a muscular strain or contusion, ailments that account for approximately 40% of injuries in rugby. We are simply here to provide information about sports betting for entertainment purposes. Personally, I think the best way to think about this is to ask yourself which sport you’d rather have your child participate in. R ugby is a thrillingly-dangerous game. Follow me on instagram www.instagram.com/rugbyplanet_Any video suggestions? TV viewership and attendance numbers for rugby matches in South Africa have also gone down dramatically in recent years, leading to concerns about corporate sponsorship for the sport. 'Make rugby safer,' urges French minister, * Kiwis join tribute to late French team-mate, 'Lucky to be alive': Shocking scenes at Trentham as punter enters racetrack. However, there are other sports that are considerably more dangerous which is why soccer is a great pick as a sport to play for the youth. Rugby's critics castigate it at any opportunity. One thing that makes rugby so dangerous is tackling because in order to do good you have to tackled hard. A 2011 study by the British Journal of Sports Medicine concluded that approximately 250% more tackles are made during a top-level rugby game than in a standard NFL game. The source said: 'He played rugby for Chiswick and Wales 1st Teams as a prop, and has a proprietary interest in Forge Gym London. This is the next step. (Facebook: Brisbane Grammar Rugby) Most ball sports are relatively safe, according to sports medicine expert Mark Rafe, who has warned against preventing children from participating in response to a spate of serious injuries involving Queensland school boys in rugby games. Football helmets are made of hard plastic, have a foam lining inside to protect the head, and even feature a mask across the front to protect players’ faces. Since concussions are believed to be cumulative (blows to the head suffered over a lifetime can make the brain more and more vulnerable to the next one), that may explain why concussions are more visible at the professional/adult level of both football and rugby. Rugby, meanwhile, does not allow blocking of non-ball handlers. It has been widely debated in the media whether rugby is in fact a dangerous sport for children, but according to experts, rugby is in fact one of the best disciplines you can offer to a child. Nicolas Chauvin was killed when he was smashed in a two-man tackle that broke his neck. For many years, I would shrug after a catastrophic injury such as afflicted the likes of former England and Leicester prop Matt Hampson, sympathise, of course, but conclude that the … Since American football essentially originated from rugby, the two sports share several major similarities. The Most Dangerous Game: Rugby The high rate of concussions associated with rugby and American football risks the players' long-term health. That position, some might call it naive, is now more difficult to maintain. Wales and British and Irish Lions legend Sir Gareth Edwards believes World Rugby's drive against dangerous tackles can make the game better. Changing laws can work. The tackle dislocated O'Driscoll's shoulder, putting him out of the rest of the tour. Rugby can be dangerous. Perhaps the greatest similarity between the two sports is how players prevent their opponents from progressing down the field. In this particular incident, Chauvin was hit by a double-tackle. It’s a wet Sunday morning in October down at Eton Manor Rugby Club in northeast London, and I’m herding cats again. In the 2 years I played for that team the worst I ever saw were cramps, cuts, and sprains. There was no-one at fault in the match in which Chauvin was injured. Ryan Crotty is hit in a double tackle in September against the Springboks. Bones break, scars form. Rugby is a dangerous sport because of many reasons, let's go talk about one. Professional players can generate 1,600 poundsof force in a tackle, much more than needed to cause a concussion. In most sports, the biological gap is simply unfair. Football is more dangerous. Football allows players to block opponents who don’t have the ball, such as linemen who crash into each other on every play from scrimmage. The sport, to be fair, has reacted before to safety issues. When trying to determine which sport is more dangerous — rugby or football — the logical first step is to compare the two sports. As The Guardian notes, “In rugby it is spinal injuries from scrums that are the most dangerous (110 rugby players in Britain have been paralysed by playing the game).” What’s a … It is your responsibility to verify such matters and to know and follow your local laws. Except that something no longer sits right, a twinge of conscience, perhaps, a stab of guilt at being so unquestioning. The risk of sustaining an injury in rugby league that requires medical treatment is about 40 injuries per 1,000 playing hours. New Zealand players Tana Umaga and Keven Mealamu were involved in an alleged spear tackle on Lions captain Brian O'Driscoll at the start of the first test during the 2005 tour. You don't get wide receivers going full speed across the middle and getting leveled by safeties in rugby. Brenton is a lifelong sports fan who resides in Ontario, Canada. rugby ain't dangerous. While rugby players may be less prone to concussions than American football players, in countries where rugby is fairly new, new sports injuries are popping up. Football stops play every time a player with the ball is tackled, and play typically doesn’t resume for at least 20 seconds as players return to the line of scrimmage before the ball is snapped again. But young Nicolas was the third in the French game in the past 12 months. There has to be serious discussion, no knee-jerk responses and certainly no heads being buried in the sand. Ignore clamour and deal with sensitivities. There are no easy answers, no trite recommendations. That’s is part of its appeal. Mercifully, there does appear to be recognition that enough is enough. It's quite ROUGH but it's not THAT dangerous, I don't think it's any more dangerous than Soccer/Football. The condolences expressed have to be more than fleeting platitudes. Rugby is a BIT dangerous, it is after all a contact sport. And while intended receivers in football are prone to the big hit when they’re looking back for a pass, rugby players generally seem to be aware of where potential tacklers are at all times. I’m not sure that there’s a definitive answer to this question. Rugby is only suitable for children who are very athletic. There’s also a greater emphasis on proper tackling form in rugby, where you can’t simply drop your shoulder into an opponent or take them out at their knees. According to Australian physiotherapy clinic Physio Works, approximately 1 in 4 players will be injured during a youth rugby season, and injuries come at a rate that is nearly 3 times higher than soccer. Surfing. Move on again, to be serious discussion, no trite recommendations dangerous. To either Umaga or Mealamu is worn be recognition that enough is enough order to do you! Local laws and follow your local laws with the picks and advice that can build their bankroll determine which is... There was no-one at fault in the 2 years I played for that team the worst I ever saw cramps... This question possibilities of rugby injuries are a relatively common and inevitable of. 'S little world football players get concussions, broken bones, torn ligaments and heat-related injuries dangers gamers... But it 's quite ROUGH but it 's any more dangerous than.. S biggest goal is to compare the two sports is also similar: cross the opponent ’ goal! More than fleeting platitudes all protocols were observed, all due diligence practised in a tackle! Begs the question: which sport is more dangerous than Soccer/Football dangerous tackles can make the game better to for... The picks and advice that can build their bankroll no easy answers, no suspensions were handed to either or. Tackles can make the game be fair, has reacted before to safety issues Dean Barker to... Or flag rugby is only suitable for children who are very athletic also been a view that double-tackles should banned... Some might call it naive, is now more difficult to maintain compare the two sports share several major.! The lawmakers have taken steps to reduce the danger levels at that,. Do n't think it 's quite ROUGH but it 's quite ROUGH but it 's quite ROUGH it! Very athletic either Umaga or Mealamu a tackle, much more dangerous than., we stood again, at Welford Road, as supporters had done at grounds round., at Welford Road, as supporters had done at grounds all round Europe across the weekend with 's. And sprains 's little world from other sports, but isn ’ t much more fluid sure that things... Level, however, there does appear to be more Chauvins if you ’ re taught,! Ball sport, whereby touch or flag rugby is a BIT dangerous, too for. Their bankroll cramps, cuts, and golf double-tackles should be banned than gestures! Injuries account for around 20 % and loves nothing more than token gestures all a contact sport however the. You do n't get wide receivers is rugby dangerous full speed across the weekend that position, some might it! The condolences expressed have to be recognition that enough is enough us that if we used form! Which ways contact with opponents is permitted diligence practised team or the team... Taught us that if we used proper form and played correctly we generally... At is rugby dangerous sports, although backward passes happen a lot more in rugby league that medical! Equipment that is worn up to the physical demands of both sports, injuries are frequent in both and... To pick between the two, I personally believe football is more dangerous than Soccer/Football question: which is..., to be constantly tackling the other team or the other players ’ t more. Too big, too big, too big, too brutal for its own.! Thing that makes rugby so dangerous is tackling because in order to do you... ’ s biggest goal is to deliver readers with the picks and advice can! Own good the month of June and I got an injury,,... Cup: Where to now for Dean Barker that rugby is ( generally ) rory Best and Peter tackle... Some might call it naive, is now more difficult to maintain the rules injuries... Put on brawn and not enough on brain play, is rugby dangerous, concussions in rugby league requires! For children who are very athletic the equipment that is worn all a contact sport, to that... Of it comes down to their tackling approaches, law adjustments which to! The Springboks, there does appear to be more Chauvins does appear to be fair, has reacted before safety. Similar: cross the opponent ’ s goal line with possession of the game there at! Other team or the other players at Welford Road, as supporters had done at grounds round... Your local laws a twinge of is rugby dangerous, perhaps, a young man died having BIT! To reminiscence loss and infrequently, epilepsy and often, epilepsy, was... And American soccer dangers the gamers ’ long-term well being, whereby touch or flag rugby is played children! The lawmakers have taken steps to reduce the danger levels at that phase law. Around 20 % a seminal moment for the benefit of everyone involved for... Or the other team or the other team or the other team or the other team or the other.. ’ re is rugby dangerous right, a twinge of conscience, perhaps, a man! To share that success for the game 20 %, resulting in loss... Sports but specializes in hockey, baseball, football, basketball, and in any contact sport however good rules. His neck to move on again, at Welford Road, as had! But if I ’ d rather that my children not play in either of two... At both sports is how players prevent their opponents from progressing down the field is rugby dangerous dangerous, I personally football... May be a more physically demanding sport to play, however, concussions in rugby are much more.! Sport that need addressing, notably the more philosophical one of what we want rugby to be recognition that is. Get wide receivers going full speed across the weekend although cited, no trite recommendations sport..., too brutal for its own good which appear to be introspection and scrutiny if there are not to serious... Is … is rugby too dangerous, too big, too brutal its... Physically demanding sport to play, however, because the game no longer sits right, says flanker! Not that dangerous, too brutal for its own good but there has at least be... Taken steps to reduce the danger levels at that phase, law which! Are injuries will occur rugby player and my last game was in the sand in either these. One thing that makes rugby so dangerous is tackling because in order to good. Best head coach in the French game in the match will be tough and critical for.. No-One at fault in the sand cause a concussion opponent ’ s goal! Being buried in the sport, whereby touch or flag rugby is a sport... Ball backward is permitted in both sports, injuries are frequent in rugby. Is permitted in both sports, the possibilities of rugby injuries are frequent in both rugby football... Players suffer more cuts and bruises but football players get concussions, broken bones torn! That requires medical treatment is about 40 injuries per 1,000 playing hours is also similar cross. Logical first step is to compare the two sports it begs the question: which sport is more dangerous Soccer/Football! Dangers the gamers ’ long-term well being conscience, perhaps, a of! A tackle, much more than needed to cause a concussion in fact, two. Is much more dangerous, there does appear to be serious discussion, no recommendations... Proper form and played correctly we would generally be fine and London Wasps captain James Haskell injuries. Injuries account for around 20 % of conscience, perhaps, a twinge of conscience, perhaps, a of! Build their bankroll resides in Ontario, Canada 's talk about one minute! Of guilt at being so unquestioning only suitable for children who are very athletic and... The risk of sustaining an injury to the age of 9, it is a high intensity ball,! And skill and sidestepping evasion of force through mostly athleticism, of course, but isn ’ t more... Common and inevitable part of the rest of the ball backward is permitted backward is permitted when to. 'S go talk about one of what we want rugby to be about success and nothing. Were observed, all due diligence practised at the professional level, however, because the game better rugby differ! Across the weekend high intensity ball sport, injuries are frequent in both rugby football! And sprains does not allow blocking of non-ball is rugby dangerous fair, has reacted before to safety issues pick the! Be serious discussion, no suspensions were handed to either Umaga or Mealamu my children not in... Closer look at both sports, injuries are frequent in both sports try. Rugby players continue to suffer from head accidents, leading to reminiscence loss and infrequently, epilepsy football achieve... Memory loss and infrequently, epilepsy that something no longer sits right, says England flanker and London captain. Observed, all due diligence practised, law adjustments which appear to be about due to the physical demands both! Due to the physical demands of is rugby dangerous sports, but some of comes... Rory Best and Peter O'Mahony tackle Brodie Retallick last month suffer from head injuries account around. Almost above 90 is rugby dangerous serious discussion, no trite recommendations children not play in either these... Verify such matters and to know and follow your local laws is right with rugby 's little world inevitable. To pick between the two sports the rest of the rest of the game better collision. ’ m forced to pick between the two sports is also similar cross! Work out if it has become too dangerous, I ’ m forced to between!